Previous Winners

Season One Winners:

Best Pony – Blueberry Hill By: Lillia E
Best Darry – A Week Without Pony By: Usagibuffy
Best Soda – The Right Side of Wrong By: runaway-run
Best Johnny – Johnny By: Mad Crazy Molly
Best Dally – Slashed Tires By: Zevie
Best Steve – Behind Blue Eyes By: Hairibo (Alli)
Best Two-Bit – No winner due to disqualification of nominee.
Best Group – Safety in Numbers By: Scarlett7
Best Other – Truth Be Told By: Katie (under penname Kelby)
Honorary Mention (Other) – Curly Shepard By: Goddess of Sarcasm
Best Comedy – Finn By: Tensleep
Best Romance – Five for Fighting By: Antique Orange
Best AU – Project Zodiac By: Catherine Ace
Best Tragedy – Helpless By: Antigone
Best Drama – He Looked Right Through Me By: ModestVanity
Honorary Mention (Drama) – Silent Sighs and Sand Dollar Scribbles By: Mad Crazy Molly
Best Action – No winner due to lack of nominations.
Best Suspense – Safety in Numbers By: Scarlett7
Best Original – Different View By: Tensleep
Best Novel – Fitting In – The Way of the Teenager By: Mad Crazy Molly
Best Novella – No winner due to lack of nominee.
Best Short – Precious Mr. Tinker By: Talaco
Best Sequel – Robbie Cade By: ohio-girl13
Best Unfinished – Precursor By: zevie and Molly
Best Poem – Voyage of Dreams By: Goddess of Sarcasm
Best Friend – Finn By: Tensleep
Best OC – Finn By: Tensleep
Best Villain – Safety in Numbers By: Scarlett7
Webmistresses Choice – Different View By: Tensleep

Season Two – Discontinued. No winners.

Season Three Winners:

Best Pony: Ponyboy’s Nightmare By: Ivy 45663
Best Darry: Not Today By: Desert-girl
Best Soda: Family TiesBy: Print and Polish
Best Johnny: Fight or Flight By: Marsonfire
Best Dally: Epiphany by Emiline Harris and Tough Like Me By: Marauder and the Q
Best Steve: Running on Empty By: Emiline Harris
Best Two-Bit: Middle Ground By: Marsonfire
Best Gang: Come Down From Your Fences By: Maxiekat
Best Minor: The Unforgiven By: Fairlane
Best New Addition: Different View By: Tensleep
Best Comedy/Humor: Kools Ain’t For Kids By: Marauder and the Q
Best Romance: Welcome To The Wrong Side Of The Tracks By: Artemis Rex
Best AU/Sci-Fi: Epiphany By: EmilineHarris and Running In the Dark By: Misosoop
Best Tragedy/Tear-jerker: Going Home Again By: Print and Polish
Best Drama/Angst: Changing Tides By: Feisty Feist and Ponyboy’s Nightmare By: Ivy45663
Best Action/Adventure: Get Over It By: Demonically Angelic
Best Thriller: Do You Believe? By: Hairibo
Best Original: My Canadian Cousin By: Tensleep
Best Novel: Ten Years Later By: NittanyLizard
Best Novella: If The Sun Comes Up Tomorrow By: Artemis Rex
Best Short: Mercury Knew By: Aiko-Chan
Best Unfinished: Saving Grace By: Artemis Rex
Best Poem: The Outsiders By: The Motorcycle Boy Reigns
Best Villian: Keeping Darry Happy By: pyroJoe

*Please note that some of these stories no longer exist on fanfiction.net and therefore may show up as non-existant.